FAQ

Latest News

Warning - Don't Be Scammed!

man holding blocks that spell the word scam

Brethren Mutual Insurance Company does not call policyholders directly to request a payment over the phone. Additionally, Brethren Mutual does not call policyholders directly to notify them that a policy has cancelled and payment is required to be made over the phone to reinstate the policy. All payment requests from Brethren Mutual are documented in writing and mailed or e-delivered to policyholders. On occasion, a Brethren Mutual Policyholder Services Representative may follow-up with a policyholder over the phone regarding a payment. In this instance, the Brethren Mutual representative will identify themselves and reference the policy number and reason for the call. Under no circumstance does a Brethren Mutual representative "cold call" a policyholder asking for payment. If you receive a suspicious call or e-mail, please contact your Brethren Mutual agent or the Company directly at 800-621-4264.


Save a Tree With eDelivery

help us save trees with eDelivery

Brethren Mutual now offers policyholders paperless policies, invoices and correspondence in an environmentally friendly way! By signing up for eDelivery, policyholders will receive notifications in their inbox letting them know when a policy is available for review, a payment is due, or a special notice needs to be reviewed and responded to. Enroll today by logging-in to www.bmic.com with your email and password. Click on the Account tab and select the policies to be eDelivered.


Identity Fraud Expense Coverage

identity theft holding credit card

You may not think it could ever happen to you. However, many individuals today are dealing with the burden and expense of clearing their credit, financial and personal information after becoming a victim of identity fraud. To learn more about Identity Fraud Expense Coverage, click here to download our product brochure.


Reward Your Young Driver

young driver

Brethren Mutual rewards young drivers with better driving records with a lower premium on your car insurance. If you answer yes to the following questions, your young driver may qualify for a lower Personal Auto premium:
than 5 years dr
Does your young driver have less iving experience?
Does your young driver have a clean driving record?
Does your young driver reside in your household?
Does Brethren Mutual insure your personal auto?

To find out more about saving money on your car insurance, contact a Brethren Mutual independent agent. Be sure to ask about the good student discount for even more savings!


Your Condo Association Has Insurance...And So Should You!

condo owners

Condominium association insurance covers the condominium building, commonly owned property, and liability insurance for the association. However, the association insurance does not protect you from losses to your personal property and the interior of your unit. A Brethren Mutual Condo Policy provides you with protection for the contents of the unit and your personal belongings against a covered loss - such as a fire.

To learn more about our Condo product, click here to download a Condo brochure specifically developed for Maryland and Pennsylvania residents or click here to download a Condo brochure for Virginia residents. For a competitive quote, contact a Brethren Mutual independent agent.

Contact Us

Brethren Mutual's Policyholder
Services Department

(800) 621-4264
Email: Policyholder Services

Mailing Address
149 North Edgewood Drive
Hagerstown, MD  21740
Driving Directions
Office Hours